Restaurants, Bars, Grills and Eateries

Besides the household names commonly associated with a quick meal like Subway and McDonalds, New Buffalo, Michigan has some unique independent restaurants that will appeal just about everybody.

  • Bentwood Tavern
    Marina Grand Resort
    600 W. Water St.
    New Buffalo, MI 49117

  • Brewsters Italian Cafe
    Wood-fired Pizza, Pasta, Salads, & Deli
    11 W. Merchant Street
    New Buffalo, MI 49117
    (269) 469-3005

  • (The) Buffet
    Four Winds Casino Resort
    11111 Wilson Rd.
    New Buffalo, MI 49117
    (866) 494-6371

  • Casey’s Bar & Grill
    American Cuisine – late night dining
    136 N. Whittaker Street
    New Buffalo, MI 49117
    (269) 469-6400

  • Beachside Scoops
    formerly Mooney’s Blue Moon Ice Cream
    225 N. Whittaker St.
    New Buffalo, MI 49117
    (269) 469-6666

  • Cafe Tuscany
    16321 Red Arrow Hwy
    New Buffalo, MI 49117
    (269) 469-9094
  • Capozio’s
    13982 Red Arrow Highway
    New Buffalo, MI 49117
    (269) 469-4001
  • Copper Rock Steakhouse
    Four Winds Casino Resort
    11113 Wilson Rd
    New Buffalo, MI 49117

  • David’s Delicatessen
    30 N. Whittaker St.
    New Buffalo, MI 49117
    (269) 469-7177

  • Dinner’s Ready…Set…Go!
    424 E. Buffalo St
    New Buffalo, MI 49117
    (269) 469-1702
  • El Rancho Grande
    310 E. Buffalo Street
    New Buffalo, MI 49117
    (269) 469-9600

  • Fresco
    108 North Whittaker St.
    New Buffalo, MI 49117
    (269) 612-4000
  • Hard Rock Cafe
    Four Winds Casino Resort
    11111 Wilson Rd.
    New Buffalo, MI 49117
    (866) 494-6371

  • Jackie’s Cafe
    801 W. Buffalo St
    New Buffalo, MI 49117
    (269) 469-1800

  • Luisa’s Cafe
    13698 Red Arrow Hwy
    New Buffalo, MI 49117
    (269) 469-9037

  • McDonalds
    18881 La Porte Rd.
    New Buffalo, MI 49117
    (269) 469-1924
  • Nancy’s
    Walk-up treats & Hot Dogs
    142 N Whittaker St
    New Buffalo, MI 49117
    (269) 469-4240

  • New Buffalo Bill’s
    Wood-fired pit BBQ
    600 E. Buffalo St.
    New Buffalo, MI 49117
  • Oinks Dutch Treat
    Ice cream & atmosphere!
    227 W Buffalo St (across from City Hall)
    New Buffalo, MI 49117
    (269) 469-3535

  • Pierre Anne Creperie
    9 South Barton St.
    New Buffalo, MI 49117
    (269) 469-9542

  • Pizza Hut/Wings Street
    700 E. Buffalo St
    New Buffalo, MI 49117
    (269) 469-6900
  • Promeny Café
    910 W Buffalo St.
    New Buffalo, MI 49117
    (269) 469-9957

  • Redamak’s
    Popular Seasonal Hangout – Burgers
    616 East Buffalo St
    New Buffalo, MI 49117
    (269) 469-4522

  • Redamak’s at the Beach
    Beach-front Snack Bar
    @ the Public Beach
    New Buffalo, MI 49117
  • Roma Pizza
    17600 Red Arrow Hwy
    New Buffalo, MI 49117
    (269) 469-3698

  • Rios Mexican Food
    901 W Buffalo St.
    New Buffalo, MI 49117
    (269) 469-8011

  • Rosie’s Restaurant
    American cuisine
    128 North Whittaker St.
    New Buffalo, MI 49117
    (269) 469-4382

  • Skip’s Restaurant & Catering
    Prime Rib & steaks
    16710 Lakeshore Road
    New Buffalo, MI 49117
    Shuttle Bus Available
    (269) 469-3330

  • Song Asian Cuisine
    301 W. Buffalo St (US-12)
    New Buffalo, MI 49117
    (269) 586-3699
  • Stray Dog Bar & Grill
    Breakfast/Brunch, Late Night
    245 North Whittaker Street
    New Buffalo, MI 49117
    (269) 469-2727

  • Subway Sandwiches & Salads
    207 N Whittaker St.
    New Buffalo, MI 49117
    (616) 469-5055
  • Terrace Cafe & Lounge
    at the Harbor Grand
    111 West Water Street
    New Buffalo, MI 49117

  • The Lakehouse Pub
    310 W. Buffalo St.
    New Buffalo, MI 49117
    (269) 469-2247
  • Timbers Fast Food & Deli
    Four Winds Casino Resort
    11111 Wilson Rd.
    New Buffalo, MI 49117
    (866) 494-6371
  • Villa Nova Pizzeria
    134 W. Buffalo St.
    New Buffalo, MI 49117
    (269) 469-0200

  • Whittaker Woods
    12578 Wilson Rd
    New Buffalo, MI 49117
    (269) 469-3400
  • Zoe’s Gourmet
    910 W Buffalo St.
    New Buffalo, MI 49117
    (269) 586-0200